In The Den with Mama Dragons
You're navigating parenting an LGBTQ+ child without a manual and knowing what to do and what to say isn't always easy. Each week we’ll visit with other parents of queer kids, talk with members of the LGBTQ+ community, learn from experts, and together explore ways to better parent our LGBTQ+ children. Join with us as we walk and talk with you through this journey of raising healthy, happy, and productive LGBTQ+ humans.
In The Den with Mama Dragons
Embracing Hopelessness
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Today’s episode will tackle the topic of hopelessness, which might seem like a strange thing to spend an hour talking about, especially for those of us who are doing justice work, who care deeply about our communities and about creating a different kind of world. We’re often told that hope is what keeps us going–hope for the future, hope for the next generation, hope that we’ve been here before and somehow we’ll find our way through this, too. When people talk about having hope for the future or trusting that things will eventually get better, sometimes that can fall flat for many of us. It might even feel like it lets us off the hook, because if we know everything will be okay, what exactly is being asked of us right now? Maybe letting go of the need to believe in a particular outcome, of embracing hopelessness, can actually free us to focus on what we can do, who we love, and what matters to us right now. Today’s In the Den discussion explores a different angle than some of us may have considered before, but hopefully this candid talk about hopelessness can give many of us a meaningful way forward when hope is hard to find.
Special Guest: The Reverend Darcy Baxter
Rev. Darcy Baxter is long-time reproductive justice activist, who currently serves as the parish minister at the Unitarian Universalist congregation in Modesto, CA. She is a member of the Center for American Progress' Faith and Reproductive Justice Leadership Institute and has just finished serving on the Leadership Board for the Abortion Conversation Project.
Special Guest: The Reverend Lucas Hergert
The Reverend Lucas Hergert became the Minister of North Shore Unitarian Church in 2017. He has been one of the organizers for the demonstrations around the Broadview detention facilities in Chicago, and also advocates for trans rights. In addition to serving as a minister, he teaches preaching at Meadville Lombard Theological School and is the author of Impassioned: A Guide to Progressive Preaching. His interests include yoga, Shakespeare plays, biking, liberation theologies, fantasy novels, interfaith work, and humor.
Links from the Show:
- Join Mama Dragons today
- Review paper on hope fatigue
- I Eat the Stars by Sarah Wilson
- Feeling Backward by Heather Love
- The Promise of Happiness by Sara Ahmed
Go deeper with Empowered Parent Learning - Mama Dragons’ on-demand library of video courses and webinars for parents of LGBTQ+ kids. Two tracks: Parenting Essentials and Parent Advocacy. Free for Mama Dragons members, a small one-time fee for everyone else. Includes Suicide Prevention Training and Parachute eLearning.
In the Den is made possible by generous donors like you. Help us continue to deliver quality content by becoming a donor today at www.mamadragons.org.
Connect with Mama Dragons:
Website
Instagram
Facebook
Donate to this podcast
SARA: Hi, everyone. Welcome to In the Den with Mama Dragons, a podcast and community to support, educate, and empower parents on the journey of raising happy and healthy LGBTQ+ humans. I’m your host, Sara LaWall. I’m a Mama Dragon myself and an advocate for our queer community. And I’m so glad to be part of this wild and wonderful parenting journey with all of you. Thanks for joining us. We’re so glad you’re here.
Hello, Mama Dragons. Today's episode is going to be a little bit different than usual because there's a topic that I've been ruminating on for quite a while now. And I find myself coming back to it again, and again, and talking about it with the podcast team. Not because I have any answers, but because I have a lot of questions. So, rather than doing a traditional interview today, I've invited a couple of my colleagues to join me In the Den for a deep conversation. And our topic is hopelessness, which might seem like a strange thing to spend an hour talking about, especially for those of us who are doing advocacy and justice work, who deeply care about our communities and our queer kids, and creating a different kind of world. Because so often in our culture the messages we get are that hope is what should keep us going, and we should hope for the future, and we have hope in the next generation, and hope that we've been here before and somehow we’ll find our way through this too. But I keep wondering: is hope always helpful? When we talk about having hope for the future or trusting that things will eventually get better, it just sometimes falls flat for me. It sometimes feels like it might let us off the hook. So let me introduce you to the guests who are going to dive into this topic with me today. Two dear friends and colleagues who have also been thinking and writing a lot about this lately, particularly in this political moment. With us In the Den are the Reverend Dr. Lucas Hergert, the Unitarian Universalist Minister of the North Shore UU church in Illinois. Lucas was also previously a college faculty member and I think still is.
LUCAS: Yeah.
SARA: Teaching courses in philosophy and comparative religion. And joining Lucas is the Reverend Darcy Baxter, Unitarian Universalist Minister of the UU Fellowship of Stanislaus County in Modesto, California. Darcy is a third-generation Unitarian Universalist whose ministry focuses on radical love and justice. Both of them are brilliant minds, beautiful writers and deep thinkers. And so we are really going to dig deep into this hope and hopelessness struggle. And I'm looking forward to this conversation so much. Lucas and Darcy, welcome In the Den. Thanks friends for joining me with this conversation today.
LUCAS: Thanks for having me.
DARCY: Yeah, good to be here.
SARA: So, Lucas, I'm going to start with you because I distinctly remember a few years ago when we were in our study group together, you were saying quite emphatically that you don't believe in hope anymore. And I remember feeling kind of floored because I think part of me at that time still held on to this idea that ministers are supposed to have hope, that we're supposed to be like a vessel for people who have lost hope. And then my life had some major challenges that flipped things upside down and I found myself kind of sinking into a despair, but always remembering your words, which helped me feel like maybe it was okay to feel hopeless. So, tell us about how you came to this place of no longer believing in hope.
LUCAS: Yeah, such a great, important conversation. And it's been something that I’ve thought about for several years now. And I think that there are a number of factors in the world right now that point to really bleak circumstances, especially when it comes to the reversal of a lot of the rights that we took for granted, for women, for LGBTQ people, and for others. I think also though, kind of looking at it a bit more widely and thinking about climate change and just how we're not mitigating that, and then how it really does not seem like there's any plan or available alternative to just unbridled capitalism kind of going out of control. It's made me, it's challenged me in some pretty deep ways. And I also am someone who came into ministry with a set of expectations that the minister is expected to be the kind of the standard bearer of hope, like basically to be like, “No. It's hopeful. It's possible. It's going to change.” What I started to find for myself is that – well, a couple of things – one is that there's a whole area of studies that has emerged and it's called Hope Fatigue Studies. And Hope Fatigue Studies focuses on the psychological issues that come up for people when they're chronically hopeful, but they're confronted again and again with circumstances that contradict their hope. And I think that with religious leaders, us being in a role where we have to bear that hope for others and then encountering so many setbacks and obstacles in the world, that puts us in a sort of position to be uniquely burned out around hope. But the other thing is that I started to feel that, to the extent that I sort of anchored the legitimacy of my activism – and I can talk later about that, kind of the things that I do as an activist – but the legitimacy of my activism in specific outcomes that I had expected or needed to happen, the more immobilized my activism became. Ironically, by letting go of hope that I was going to see certain changes, I was actually freed to engage in activism in a more deep and sustained way. And so those have been parts of my journey. I can talk about more but I’ll stop there so you can ask more questions.
SARA: That resonates with me. That was surprising about how I felt a kind of lightness and freedom, I guess, in the activism, a relief in a way. Darcy, what about you? What are you thinking as you're hearing this conversation? And where are you on the hope spectrum?
DARCY: Well, first of all, can we define, most people know what hope is. I'm curious about how we are actually defining it.
SARA: How are we defining hope, because I kind of don't try to anymore.
DARCY: Right. And I think particularly in the Unitarian Universalist context and the context of liberal theology, is it like belief that things get better?
LUCAS: Mm-hmm.
DARCY: Right, is that what we mean?
SARA: I think that is certainly a part of it and for most people.
LUCAS: Yeah, I would say the only thing I would add to that is that I think it's both belief and I think it's this kind of like effective embodied. . .
DARCY: Yes.
LUCAS: . . . investment. I think there's an emotional component as well as an intellectual component that yes, things are going to get better. That's how I would define it.
DARCY: Yeah, so I think that's helpful because you're right. There's also a belief cognitive aspect but then also in your bodies, their posture, right, like a sensation of sorts. So I think there are those two components of it. And what I am drawn to is having a conversation with Lucas leading up to the 2020 election, which was COVID and Trump’s reelection. And am I remembering it correctly, Lucas, that you were convinced that Trump was going to get reelected?
LUCAS: I was, yeah.
DARCY: So you and I heard this conversation, just like many of us were of how to – all those constellation of factors. It's so hard because it's been so dense, right? There's all this awful, we could like, any particular moment in the past ten years you can, “Wait, what was the awfulness then?” And my recollection is I am choosing to believe in unpredictability and that things are not nearly as controllable. And the way we always try to focus, to make predictions, because there's that human need to know that it will get better. And so I was puzzled, like I'm not hopeful or hopeless. But I think in like unpredictability or that there is just too much chaos. And finding that is the only way in that moment to not be set in this kind of like, “Oh, it's definitely going to happen.” But finding comfort in the unpredictability and messiness, like, who knows what could happen? And I can continue. And I'm blanking on that. That's not my original thought. I don't know if that comes – I'm trying to think if that's something out of Katherine Keller and process theology. I'm blanking because I remember engaging with something very specifically, which is just that the messiness of the world, it is too much for human management. And rather than deciding to find comfort in knowing, because I think oftentimes we're like,”Well, we need to know what's going to happen. And it's better to think that we know the awful thing is going to happen.” Rather than to entertain that there's a lot more unpredictability and chaos than we like to think. And oftentimes that can scare a person that I think when it's like, “Well, we're definitely going to get this.” Where the path is going is trying to tap into a sense of the chaos and unpredictability. And that can go either way, but that it’s not so set.
SARA: Yeah, Darcy, I've heard you use the word precarity a lot in all kinds of different conversations. And I'm thinking about that now, as you're talking, I'm thinking that is really a useful point here in sort of leaning further into the precariousness of life.
DARCY: Yeah, which that's a Judith Butler book. She got me turned on to the idea of the precariousness. Yeah, right? Life is way more precarious than we often are in touch or feel with. And that's a great, important psychological defense mechanism, is not needing to live and feel the risk that we all engage with, right? Even if we're driving on the highway I grew up with a dad in insurance. And he told me the most dangerous thing you will likely do is drive on the interstate. Right. But I drive on the interstate all the time and I am not living in the death grip of fear even though I'm like statistically speaking this is probably pretty dangerous
SARA: I've been reading this new book by Sarah Wilson called I Eat the Stars. She's a climate activist and the tie line of the book is how to live fully and beautifully in a collapsing world. She spends the whole first part of the book talking about her giving up on hope and why. And she calls it, hope-ium that I rather love.
DARCY: Oh, I like it.
LUCAS: Yep.
SARA: I rather let hope-ium. That it can become a kind of drug that takes us out of the call and what is needed from us in the moment. Where do you think this idea that hope is inherently good and important and we must have it comes from? What's missing when we just assume hope is always good or always helpful?
DARCY: Do you know that? That's like an intellectual, historical question.
SARA: Well, what do you think?
LUCAS: Yeah. Well, a little bit of a sense of it just because I've done a lot of reading on this recently, but one of the really interesting things about the ancient world – there's a story of Pandora's box and if listeners aren't familiar with that, it's the idea. It's actually a jar. I had learned it was a jar and Pandora's given this jar by Zeus. And it's a gift because she has all of these different abilities and capacities. And the gods are honoring her. And so Zeus gives her this jar. And it's actually a curse and it's vengeance for something else that had happened. And she opened it and all the evils of the world rushed out. And the thing that is left in there is hope. That's the very last thing that is in the jar. Now, I had always heard that story and I thought that hope was like a good thing, it was like, “Okay. This is what will sustain us in a really bleak and difficult world. That's what the story is getting at.” What was really interesting was to learn that the ancients actually did not think hope was a virtue. They more often than not thought it was a vice. And they thought that it was the last evil in a jar. And the reason they thought that is, the way they used hope, it was more like how we would use like wishful thinking, just this unrealistic, high expectations against the reality of circumstances that might, themselves, be tragic. The way it kind of developed is that Christianity picked it up. And then it turned into faith, hope, and love, is like the three theological virtues. But for Christianity, it's always rooted in a sense that it's like, hope in a final hope, like your salvation or the salvation of history that God will do. It was only when the Enlightenment came along and that kind of Christian narrative started to break down that it started to be secularized and turned into a virtue that anybody could have for anything. And there's been a serious philosophical debate between a group of philosophers who rely on it and think it's a really important concept and other philosophers who continue to look at it as a vice, Nietzsche and Schopenhauer, a couple of examples there. So anyway, that's a bit of the history around it.
DARCY: When you say, hope-ium, right? I mean, as a coping mechanism, obviously it's like going to opium, right, and seeking to get high and escape. And what are the circumstances many of us are really wanting to escape? And it's really these awful conditions for many, many people of late-stage capitalism, all the different aspects.
SARA: And that's really real. I just want to pause there and as we're talking about this really honor that truth and that deep reality of the collapsing world that we are living in. And so of course, we are reaching out to cope with it in all kinds of different ways.
DARCY: Right. And also capitalism offers so many mechanisms for doing that. What makes it easy is distraction. And it's really hard to access, say, mental health care. It's not affordable. It's much easier to get high. The whole system that's set up that, what is the easiest thing to do to cope with your pain? And that is far, far more accessible and affordable than the kinds of practices that expand one's capacity to cope with pain.
LUCAS: Yeah.
SARA: Yeah. I am curious how you two are thinking about hopelessness and helplessness because I think they get conflated sometimes. I think when, certainly I reveal my own personal philosophy now of welcoming hopelessness, I can see how folks sometimes interpret that to mean giving up or not doing anything. They sound kind of synonymous. How do you tease those apart? How do you distinguish between hopelessness and helplessness?
LUCAS: Yeah, that's something that I’ve thought a lot about, especially because – you had mentioned it too, Sara – that actually you felt like your activism had been energized by letting go of hope. And so I’ve thought about why that is. What is the motivation for acting when you think that a better future, improvements, are unlikely? And I think for me what it's come down to is thinking that I'm not acting because I think that these outcomes are going to happen. I've been super engaged in a lot of activism against ICE and been at the Broadview Detention Center with tear gas, mace, beaten. All of these things have happened there, which were terrifying. And I'm still engaged, even though I don't necessarily think I'm going to see a reversal in policy. And part of that is because we know under Trump, of course not. It's going to be ratcheted up. And then we can also talk about how under the Obama administration, deportations were higher. And so, it's a bipartisan agreement that ICE is the way to deal with the situation. But I continue to be really engaged. And the thing that emerged for me is that, I'm not acting because I'm going to see something better. I'm acting because – and I can't use the curse word here – but it's the right f-ing thing to do. And that to me felt very empowering because it's a letting go of outcomes. But I'm doing it because it's the right, it's what a decent person should do. I also think that it inflicts a certain level of pain on the Trump administration and on the City of Chicago, it's a disgrace that they're allowing this to happen. And to the extent that we're able to exert that kind of pressure, I do agree with Darcy that I'm not in charge of the future. I can't foresee exactly what's going to happen. Do I think it's likely? Not so much. But am I open to the idea that there could be possibility there? I am.
DARCY: Anthony Pinn, an American theologian talks about, instead of hope, persistence towards possibility. Which, in conversation, when he said this, I was like, “persistence towards possibility, because possibility is not probability, right?” And this might be a little more leading, not to be Pollyanna-ish, but a lot of awesome things that happened were not predictable either, right? You hear the stories around the Berlin Wall falling, things that are easily preachable and a hope of paradigm, right? But there is just something that you don't know will emerge, and it's not always clear what contributes to it. Right. And so this sense of participating in the persistence towards a possibility, either remote. And I also wonder whether the quality of involvement leads to a sense of alive-ment. Alive-ment, that's a great word. Alive-ness.
SARA: Alive-ment. I like alive-ment.
LUCAS: Alive-ment,I like that.
DARCY: Right?
SARA: Say more about that.
DARCY: Well, that just being empowered means you assume that your action will have an impact. And I think particularly for a lot of folks in the professional classes, right, many of us live a life where we assume that we can have effect, right, or immediate effect, right, that there can be more immediate gratification. And I think about the generation that, in many of our congregations that fought for abortion rights and civil rights. And they saw an accomplishment of something, right? And then there's this grief that now how much has been rolled back. And that younger generation is like, “Well, what does it mean to live without necessarily thinking there could be that gratification?” But I think there's something in participating with the kinds of people who are actively resisting. And I think they have a quality of a life, or alive-ment, that impacts one's body and being, not necessarily in a cognitive way, but that it feels alive to do it. And in the persistence towards possibility, who knows? But it's alive and you're inflicting pain on the enemy, which is not nothing, right, and showing resistance. And how that ends up contributing, who the hell knows. And we may never know.
SARA: And I appreciate a lot of using a lot of different language to describe other motivations that might sub in for hope but that also then, when I hear them, strength and that call to action a little bit. Like, there's something I think a little meatier there, I guess for me, as I've been kind of contemplating hopelessness a little bit. One of the other things that I've been wrestling with and thinking about, in part because hope has become such a word, a part of our vocabulary that we don't often stop to really tease out and interrogate. So we hear it just thrown out a lot. We have so much hope in the next generation. This brings me hope. And one of the things that I've been wrestling with is this wondering about if holding too tightly to hope or holding hope at the center, sometimes invites us to bypass our emotions. So, I've often thought if I am being asked or being told by culture and society, I need to be committed to hope. What do I do with my rage? What do I do with my grief? It doesn't feel compatible with hope. How do you two think about the complexity of emotion, particularly in this, I love this idea of time of collapse, of all that we're seeing kind of breakdown in front of us and where hope does or doesn't fit?
DARCY: I think that's why I use the word alive-ness so much because it encompasses that being very rageful as part of being very alive. Right?
SARA: Yeah.
DARCY: Grieving your “buttooty” off is being very alive, like the depth of alive-ness. But the thing I think that gets so scary is about how to have those experiences, but that you're not supposed to have them alone. And I think that what feels terrifying is often when we think we're in hopelessness, despair and grief because of our hyper-individualized culture. And the assumption is, “Well, if you're grieving, you should go alone in your room and cry and not have that be in community.” I think that what alive-ness is allowed to happen in the full range of human emotion in the presence of others and in community. And I imagine in the meetings, Lucas, that you've told stories about that, the kinds of feelings present, a lot of anger, a lot of that there's actually, there’s space for a kind of emotion there that might not exist in other spaces.
LUCAS: Yeah, I think that's beautifully put. I think in activist spaces, there can be – not necessarily – but there can be these spaces that open up where people are able to express a much wider range of emotions than what are considered to be more culturally acceptable or whatever. I think about this also in terms of queerness a lot. So there's some really interesting writers in the area of queer theory who dealt with the question of difficult emotions, and what it would mean to claim those rather than bypass them. And some of that has to do in queer theory with the movement in queer history towards like – at least for a while, I think it's changing now – but there was this sense of like, “Oh, we’re leaving the difficulty of the past behind. And we're going to this bright future where everybody's going to be . . .
SARA: Everybody can get married.
LUCAS: . . . everybody can get married.” Exactly. And some theorists that were really impactful for me, Heather Love was one of them. And she wrote a book called Feeling Backward. And it's a beautiful book. And what she writes about are pieces of literature from the 20th century, that were very bleak and dark about the queer experience. But she said this is a dimension of our history. And if we're able to notice this, there might be a way in which we at least, we don't necessarily need to let go of brighter emotions and pretend that those aren't there, they don't exist. But we can at least acknowledge that in some ways, queer life is not great still. And there's a lot of difficulty. And, Sara, what you're encountering, that is so relevant. And then there's another person that's been really helpful. Her name is Sara Ahmed and she wrote a book called The Promise of Happiness. And The Promise of Happiness, it's the idea that especially minorities, but queer people included, are told, “It's not that bad. Just be happy.” And what she ends up saying is that it actually might be a queer person getting in touch with their bad feelings that facilitates a revolutionary action, right? Rather than pretending like, “Oh, I'm great. You're great. We're all great under late-stage capitalism. Let’s pretend we're not suffering.” Instead, that might be like the spark. So anyway, those are a few things I think about.
DARCY: Why do we live in a system that wants to repress feeling so much? Right? Because when you just said that you get in touch with bad feelings and you're like, how not right and messed up this is? Why is it so easy to numb out, right? And take the edge off in all these ways, and not be deeply alive with the bad feelings.
SARA: So, I want to get personal for a moment. What do you two do to get in touch with and connect your alive-ness with the bad stuff and the bad feelings? You know, I even think about myself. It's just easier, sometimes to just work.
DARCY: Yeah.
SARA: And do the work, than it is for me to sit and be with the difficult feelings.
DARCY: Yeah, and I think for me what is so key about it is there's a lot of people who do not want to hang around those bad feelings, right, that just don't want to be present to it. And so it's not what I do. It's about the people I'm with and that in these spaces where those feelings are allowed. And I think about my most important dance teacher because I've been doing dance classes for 25 years. She's from El Salvador. And her fiance disappeared during the civil war there. And she offers a dance class and is always talking about it. And it's a space of both physically moving to rhythm and creating a space with a movement, which I think is important just to how to tolerate the badness, the physiologically, how you tolerate the horror and the grief and the fear in the presence of other bodies with it being explicitly both she names it, but also in her being, right, that the like awfulness and atrocity has existed, it is existing. We're facing it now. And now we're dancing and just all the ways of experiencing them.
LUCAS: Yeah, I think that's right. And I mean, I think the message we get in our society a lot is that there's something, it's like undesirable to feel rage or grief or pain or sorrow or suffering. And that, if you're experiencing those, like that's a shape of life that can be fixed. It might be fixed with medication, or fixed with the next shiny thing that is put on the market, a new car or whatever. And I'm somebody, I’m all for people using medication. I'm not against that. I actually think that using medication can enable us to get in touch with our feelings when our chemistry doesn't allow that. But in any case, the messaging around those things is that you shouldn't be feeling that and you should be feeling something else. And what does it mean to think about the shape of your life as being one that's valuable, that is precisely one that feels those things deeply.
DARCY: Yeah.
LUCAS: And that there might actually be something really impoverished by skipping over those things. And I think the longer I've just been alive and experienced grief and those sorts of things, the more I've just been, that's just true. It's almost foreign. It's become foreign to me to think, “Oh, this is just something I need to jump over.” How about you, Sara? I'm curious to hear what you think.
DARCY: Yeah.
SARA: Well, you all know in this very toxic, hideous state that is very anti-trans, very anti-queer, very Christian nationalist. And I've been here now 11 years. I think a lot about this. I think when I started, I started with a little like gauzy dream about how the advocacy and voice of liberal religion could help at least make a wedge. But as we've seen that has happened with this administration, it’s just it's only shored it up and gotten worse and worse and worse. And it's really been experiencing how much energy in activism and advocacy that isn't making a legislative or policy difference. We're not changing anybody's mind that has power. And for a while that was, I was in a really dark place about that. I was like, “What do we do? Why are we doing this? It's not having the impact,” and yet I couldn't not do it at the same time. I found myself like, I can't give up on doing the advocacy and the activism. Something is pulling me in that direction. And I think, Lucas, you get it. For me, I just sort of have been thinking a lot about just all of the deep feelings that pull me there and love, which seems awfully cliche. I know we wrestle with this a lot in our Unitarian Universalist world, but just the simplicity of saying, “I love people. I love people whose rights are being stripped away. I love people who are being held in detention or who have been threatened or killed by ICE.” And that love is an extraordinary fuel. When I was able to finally let the hope slip away and then really get in touch with the love, which comes with all of those other big fat messy feelings, then I was like, “Oh, there's something here. There's a fuel here that I hadn't really gotten in touch with before.” And it feels so much softer in a way. Right? It feels so much more tender. And so there's something about then, the activism that is coming from that place of tenderness and vulnerability instead of like, “We’re storming the castle!” And it’s just interesting. And I don't know that I have all the right words for it yet. I feel like I've really been wrestling with it. And, Darcy, I know you are the parent of young kids.
DARCY: Neurodivergent, yep.
SARA: Neurodivergent young kids in a queer household in a queer community. And I'm curious, because I think about this a lot and I know a lot of our listeners are probably thinking about this, how has this wrestling with and embrace of hopelessness changed your parenting? And I think I want to qualify that by saying I think, oftentimes, parents in our community of queer kids or folks with marginalized identities or even family members, beloveds, folks in helping professions right, we can draw this tent really wide, feel this pull to perform hope as maybe a form of protection.
DARCY: Yeah.
SARA: How does it come up in your parenting? How does it show up for you?
DARCY: Well, it's interesting because my oldest child was born in 2017. So we chose and being two women, you really got to choose to try to get pregnant. It takes a lot of effort. So it was a very intentional choice, right, to get pregnant in the Trump administration. And I don't have any words for the logic of it. Part of it was denial. I don't know. So we had our first child. We got pregnant in the early days after Trump’s election. And then we got pregnant again, COVID. We had started to try to conceive a few months before COVID hit. And then when it became clear, the lockdown wasn't going to be a short-term thing, we had to make a decision whether or not to do it again. And then again, I don't know if it's logical or rational, which I guess is to say that like I've only parented in these conditions. I've only parented under conditions of collapse. And I was also someone that saw the Trump administration's first election as deeply catastrophic, because that time I was like, “Well, maybe it won’t be that bad. Maybe all you guys concerned about Roe vs Wade.” And Roe vs. Wade is not perfect. So I have only parented under these conditions of, I'm gonna say very apparent, very loud and apparent collapse. And I guess what I would say is that the kind of relationship and the love and being so in touch with human vulnerability and what it takes to become human and, Holy cow, how long you're so dependent and vulnerable, has been deeply, philosophically, and theologically fascinating to take care of right both very young children, but then children who our systems do not fit very well. So just having to do even more and somehow the connection of how much I care about particular people and how that care fuels, like you just got to do the right thing, not because it leads to an end because it is. I don't really have clear words for it, but it's a compulsion that is very rooted in a profound sense of care and love. And again for me there is a faith, not a hope, in the complexity and messiness and unpredictability. We need to feel hopeful in order to do something. I don't think that's the right framework. But I also get suspicious of, there was some AI worker came out that was like, “Oh, in 10 years, I think there's a greater than 10% chance that AI will destroy humanity in 10 years.” There is an article in Wired Magazine, I'm blanking on the author. She's like, “I think that kind of apocalyptic thinking is a way to distract people from the real risks of war machines. That thinking, being hopeless about “oh, everything is going to end,” it short circuits people and stops engaging from these other kinds of risks that we actually might have possibly some agency over. And I just thought that was really interesting, again, this thing of who wants you to be hopeless and think there's no possibility. It’s like, how do you calibrate? And the fact is you don't know. And so you just do the freaking right thing anyways, because I feel like at the end of the day the answer is then you do the right thing now, maybe it will be effective, maybe it not. But in any of the scenarios, the answer is still solidarity, doing the right thing.
SARA: Yeah
LUCAS: Yeah. I’ll add a few things. And I love all of that. I just, also, can you still find goodness and joy? I mean, is life worth living? Can you find this juiciness and nectar? And one of things that Darcy and I do, how many months was it that we talked about Heated Rivalry and just the most trivial, silly. . .
DARCY: It was not trivial and silly. What are you talking about, Lucas?
LUCAS: . . . queer romance. And because of that and it wasn't even an escape. It was just this enlivening, something that we really enjoyed. And so that stuff is there. And I just, I don't have kids, and I really can't even speculate on exactly what is needed in a parenting situation. But I kind of imagine that with youth who might be particularly afraid or anxious about the future, emphasizing those elements of life that are still enjoyable and worth living. And there's communities that are there to be a support and really getting plugged in and connected with them. And oftentimes those communities can connect us with opportunities for activism and for creating change. Even if we don't make a reference to what exactly is going to happen, those things are all available. I just think that's a helpful frame.
SARA: Yes, I appreciate that.
DARCY: Well, it's important to name, right, that different communities have been living under fascism in the United States. We're talking about – and I'm going to very loosely say white liberals – there’s certain conditions have become more real, maybe for a lot of folks who are in our UU congregations that other communities in the United States have been living under for much, much longer. And I think about how you honor what it takes to adapt to a new reality and also just sad that it's a reality other folks have learned to adapt to.
SARA: Well, Lucas, you named this. I think that one of those communities is the queer community, particularly in this moment right now, the trans community who’s just being the centralized target of attack as a means of distraction for the war machine. And yet you are both, Darcy in your alive-ness, Lucas in what you just shared, talking about that hopelessness doesn't mean that we don't have joy or that we don’t find what makes us come alive in the moment.
DARCY: Oh, wait, who's the queer activist who said during the AIDS epidemic, “We went to the funerals in the morning. We protested in the afternoon. And we danced all night”?
SARA: We partied all night. Dan Savage
DARCY: Thank you.
SARA: I think a lot about the AIDS epidemic because, as you two were talking, I was thinking a lot about how there was just not a lot of hope. I mean people were dying every day en masse. And all that the activists could do, I mean part of the activism was you had to care for your dying loved ones.
LUCAS: Yeah.
SARA: It was the care in the dying that was in addition to trying to affect the policy change and get people to pay attention. But at the end of the day it was like we were just head-down doing the thing. And then we danced in order to keep going.
DARCY: Well, think about hip hop, right, came out of a burning down, these art forms that now capitalism has soaked up and used in all these ways. But it was something profoundly alive that came out of ruin, right? It was people experiencing alive-ness, dancing on cardboard around burning-down buildings. God, there was an image that came out of Gaza. And basically, it looked like parents, women with young children sitting on a park bench and just the children were just putzing around. But it was, like, bombed out in the background. And there's a way of persistence and people have been persisting in collapse and fascism for a really long time. And they often need really freaking good music and dancing to do it. Those are the lessons I take away.
LUCAS: Yeah.
SARA: Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. So besides Heated Rivalry, friends, which I can't believe we haven't done an episode about that. But where's the alive-ness in your own spaces? And what do you share with people about how to access that?
DARCY: Well, dance is one for me. I also live in a queer-intentional community, mini co-housing. So I think there's relationships. There's a lot of talking and laughing. And for me, there's dance. And then there's family life. Just the caring and being with awesome people and these are people who are very good at being present with shit hitting the fan in all the different ways they do.
LUCAS: Yeah, I would say, we talked a little bit earlier. I mean, when you mentioned dance, Darcy, I think having a way to move emotions through your body, especially when things are feeling heavy. I think like so much of this is an embodied conversation. It's not just one that's about cognition and belief. So recognizing that can be really helpful. And I've had a sustained yoga practice for 15 years now. I practice yoga most days. And that's been hugely helpful. And then I have lots of things that kind of bring me joy. I write fiction. This is dorky, but I read a lot of philosophy in that. And that to me, it helps me understand the world and my place in it and all of that, I find to be really helpful. And then having close friendships and all of that. I feel like, I think we have this understanding or expectation that if you were to encounter somebody that says, “Oh, I've given up hope,” or “I don't have hope,” that their life is basically just completely impoverished. And I don't experience my life that way. I feel like it’s very full and there's a tremendous amount of joy. It's just that when I approach kind of bigger social questions, I'm doing it from a different angle.
SARA: Yeah, that's a great point. That's a really great point. The other thing that I'm thinking a lot about that has been sort of – we've been talking about it. I don’t know if we just quite named it. It is both in this moment and I think it's also related to kind of reframing this idea of hope, is this real call to community care? I mean, Darcy, you have a community you live in, that I think probably has this orientation. But in all of the different spaces, in our families in our larger communities wherever we find those, turning towards just the sort of sense of how are we taking care of each other? How are we feeding each other? How are we inviting each other into spaces of alive-ness and being into what our body is and dancing and singing together? And how much that is in and of itself, its own critical activism. It is as, to me, as important as standing outside the Broadview Detention Center.
DARCY: Well, and I think I've got to jump in here first because I've been reading a lot. Sherry Turkle, sociologist, psychologist at MIT, who's been studying the human relationship with technology and how we've since like the late 1970s. And with all the conversations about AI, I get very suspicious of the ways we've been driven to seek comfort and even relationship with technology as opposed to in real humans and in physical proximity to each other because those are both relationships of care-taking. When you need care-taking to offer care but also ones of solidarity. It feels weird to say. It feels like an act of – it feels these days like it's activism to just even have bodies in physical proximity to each other.
SARA: Yeah.
DARCY: And so you talk about a call to community care. And I think in light of what's happening with what we call AI that something more basic becomes more radical, which is like how many times are you getting together in the room with other people, that being the base line. Not that that is all that's needed but that simple metric, there's a lot less of that happening than it used to. And I think that's not coincidental that it short circuits relationships that lead to resistance and even the kinds of resistances that we need now.
SARA: Yeah. I think I want to frame that for our audience just a little bit. And you got at it too, Darcy, when you're talking about your own parenting, which is just helping each other in this community that we're in, whatever communities we find ourselves, communities of parents, congregations, friends, activists. Helping each other remember that parenting, I'm going to speak to our community now, parenting our queer kids is its own radical act of activism. And it may be for some of us all that we have the capacity for. And that's enough.
LUCAS: Mm-hmm. I think that's beautifully put. Yeah. I also think that there are more micro levels of activism that people are engaged in that do make a really big difference. Even though they're not necessarily, obviously impacting a broader social structure, I can only be vague about this, but there are networks all over Chicago that find people that are in touch with people who are potentially targeted by ICE and they deliver groceries to them so that they don't have to go out in public and risk arrest. And doing that with one family, like you're not necessarily going to take down ICE. But at the same time, you are contributing to a resistance movement, to this broader thing that is happening. And you're making a real impact, one-to-one, with another human being and another family. And I just can't over-emphasize how important I find that kind of work and activism to be.
SARA: Well, and to bring it back full circle. And you don't have to have hope to do that.
LUCAS: No, that's right. Perfect. Absolutely.
SARA: This has been such an amazing conversation. I know the three of us could go several more hours together and maybe we will at a later time. But before we leave, I just want to throw back to you, anything else we didn't get to that feels important to say about hopelessness in this moment?
DARCY: I have so much fun talking about hopelessness with you guys.
SARA: Wildly fun, isn’t it.
LUCAS: I know.
DARCY: It's so fun.
SARA: We're going to go home and people are going to ask, “What did you do today?”
LUCAS: We talked about hopelessness. I guess the one thing I’ll add is that sometimes when I talk about this topic with other people, it's almost like they feel threatened because it's like, are you trying to take away my hope?
SARA: Yes
LUCAS: And that to me is not it at all. Instead, for me, it's about expanding the set of possible places we might arrive from in order to engage in activism. And what I would say to people who are tuning in is that if you're a hopeful person and that's what's getting you out there to do things and it's what's allowing you to survive under these conditions, please keep that up. And if you're somebody who doesn't necessarily feel that but didn't think that that was something that you could articulate, then hopefully something in this conversation allowed folks to see that you can arrive from a more hopeless place, too, and still find ways to engage.
DARCY: Yeah, hopefully this conversation. Pun intended, pun intended, Lucas
LUCAS: That’s right. That’s right.
SARA: I appreciate you saying that, Lucas. Yes, because it is important to me and I have shared this with so many others. I'm certainly not trying to convert anyone over to hopelessness.
LUCAS: Right.
SARA: If hope is your deal, please, thank you. Do it. I'm glad that that is what is working for you. It has all been about my own wrestling and figuring out how to keep going.
LUCAS: Absolutely. Absolutely.
SARA: Well, thank you both.
LUCAS: This was delightful. Thank you both.
DARCY: Fun, fun, fun. Thanks for organizing this, Sara. And thanks for your podcasts.
SARA: My pleasure. I hope it is enlivening and helpful to our listeners. And I'm going to put some of the links and all those wonderful books you mentioned in our show notes so folks can go find some of that great resource material. Thanks.
LUCAS: Awesome. Great. Thank you. Bye.
SARA: Before you go, everything we talked about today and a whole lot more lives in Empowered Parent Learning, our on demand library of courses and webinars for parents of LGBTQ+ kids. This is free for members and a small, one-time fee for everyone else. It includes our Suicide Prevention Training, Parachute E-learning, and so much more. The link is in our show notes. You don't have to do this alone. We're in it together.
If you enjoyed this episode, please tell your friends. Take a minute to leave us a positive rating and review wherever you are listening. Good reviews make us more visible and help us reach more folks who could benefit from this community and this podcast. If you’d like to help Mama Dragons in our mission to support, educate, and empower the parents of LGBTQ+ children, please donate at mamadragons.org or click the donate link in the show notes. For more information on Mama Dragons, our community, the podcast, follow us on Instagram or on Facebook and visit our website at mamadragons.org.